ANALYSIS: Carney Swears He Won’t Prorogue Parliament — Why No One Believes Him

ANALYSIS: Carney Swears He Won’t Prorogue Parliament — Why No One Believes Him
Credit: Adobe Stock

August 2020: The Day the Prorogation Became Synonymous with Escape

To understand why Carney’s promise rings hollow for millions of Canadians, we must go back to that summer morning when Justin Trudeau asked Governor General Julie Payette to prorogue Parliament. The official pretext—a “reset” of the government’s agenda in the midst of a pandemic—fooled no one. The Finance Committee was digging into the WE Charity scandal—the organization to which the government had entrusted a $900 million program, even as members of the Trudeau family had pocketed hundreds of thousands in fees.

The prorogation brought the committee’s work to a screeching halt. The requested documents never arrived. Testimony was cut short. And when Parliament resumed its work five weeks later, the government delivered a new Speech from the Throne as if nothing had happened. That wasn’t governance. It was memory surgery.

Harper, 2008: When Prorogation Saves a Government

Stephen Harper had taken the mechanism even further. Faced with a Liberal-NDP-Bloc Québécois coalition ready to topple him, he asked Governor General Michaëlle Jean to prorogue Parliament. The request was granted after two hours of deliberation—two hours that likely changed the course of Canadian political history. Without that prorogation, Canada would have had a coalition government led by Stéphane Dion.

The lesson that every subsequent prime minister has learned is not that prorogation is dangerous for democracy. It is that it works. And it is precisely for this reason that Carney’s promise reassures no one.

Share this post

facebook icon twitter icon linkedin icon
Copied!