ANALYSIS: Facebook, Cambridge Analytica, and the Supreme Court — Why Canada Is a Decade Behind on Privacy

ANALYSIS: Facebook, Cambridge Analytica, and the Supreme Court — Why Canada Is a Decade Behind on Privacy
Credit: Adobe Stock

The “It’s Not Our Problem” Defense

Facebook’s argument before the Supreme Court is worth examining, because it reveals a philosophy that extends far beyond this case. Michael Feder, the platform’s attorney, told the justices: “What the app does—that’s not Facebook’s business.”

Read that sentence again. A platform that hosts millions of third-party apps, grants them access to its users’ data, and builds its entire business model on sharing that data—this platform is asserting before the highest court of a G7 country that what happens to that data is none of its concern.

Phantom Consent

At the heart of the legal debate lies the concept of informed consent. The Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act (PIPEDA) requires companies to obtain meaningful consent before collecting, using, or disclosing personal information. Facebook maintains that it obtained this consent. The Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada says otherwise.

And yet, let’s be honest: how many of us actually read Facebook’s terms of service in 2014? How many knew that by taking a personality quiz, they were opening a highway to all their friends’ data? Consent may have existed on paper. In reality, it was as real as a reinforced door without a lock.

Share this post

facebook icon twitter icon linkedin icon
Copied!