ANALYSIS: The 25th Amendment: The Constitutional Weapon No One Dares to Use Against Trump

ANALYSIS: The 25th Amendment: The Constitutional Weapon No One Dares to Use Against Trump
Credit: Adobe Stock

A four-stage mechanism

The 25th Amendment contains four sections. The first three are relatively straightforward and have already been invoked without incident:

Section 1: If the president dies, resigns, or is removed from office, the vice president becomes president. This is what happened when Nixon resigned in 1974 and Gerald Ford took over.

Section 2: If the office of Vice President becomes vacant, the President appoints a new Vice President, subject to confirmation by Congress. Ford himself was appointed Vice President through this process before becoming President—the only man in American history to have held both the highest offices without ever having been elected to either.

Section 3: The president may voluntarily transfer his powers to the vice president. George W. Bush did so twice, briefly, for colonoscopies under anesthesia. Dick Cheney was president of the United States for a few hours. Twice. America survived.

Section 4—the constitutional nuclear option

And then there’s Section 4. The one commentators are talking about. The one that’s setting social media ablaze. The one that no one has ever used in nearly sixty years of its existence. And for good reason.

Section 4 allows the vice president and a majority of the Cabinet—not Congress, not the people, not the courts, but the innermost circle of the executive branch—to declare that the president is unable to discharge the powers and duties of his office. If this declaration is transmitted to the President pro tempore of the Senate and the Speaker of the House, the vice president immediately assumes presidential duties as acting president.

The key word here is “incapable.” Not “unpopular.” Not “controversial.” Not “erratic.” Not even “dangerous,” in the political sense of the term. “Incapable.” And it is in this gap between what the word means legally and what people would like it to mean that the entire current drama is playing out.

Share this post

facebook icon twitter icon linkedin icon
Copied!