ANALYSIS: When the Pentagon Summons the Pope’s Ambassador — Trump’s America No Longer Tolerates Any Dissent

ANALYSIS: When the Pentagon Summons the Pope’s Ambassador — Trump’s America No Longer Tolerates Any Dissent
Credit: Adobe Stock

Robert Francis Prevost, Son of Chicago

Leo XIV—born Robert Francis Prevost in Chicago—is not a European pope discovering America from the Vatican gardens. He knows this country. He knows its divisions, its founding myths, its sincere exceptionalism, and its imperialism disguised as a civilizing mission. That is precisely what makes him so dangerous to the Trump administration.

An Argentine pope like Francis could be dismissed with a wave of the hand: a foreigner, a progressive, a Latin American—easy to caricature. But an American pope who criticizes America? That’s a cluster bomb in the narrative of the evangelical right, which claims that God and the flag go hand in hand.

The moral voice Trump can’t buy

Since his election to the Chair of Peter, Leo XIV has become one of the most vocal critics of the conflict with Iran. Not out of ideology. Out of theology. The Church’s social doctrine, built on two millennia of reflection on just war, does not recognize the right of the strongest as the foundation of the world order. And yet, that is exactly what Colby articulated in that closed-door meeting: might makes right.

And yet, this doctrine—which Washington scorns—is the one that resonates in the parishes of Manila, Lagos, São Paulo, and Kraków. 1.4 billion Catholics versus a four-year presidential term. The spiritual arithmetic does not favor the Pentagon.

Share this post

facebook icon twitter icon linkedin icon
Copied!