Carney, the Conquest, and the Official Lie

Carney, the Conquest, and the Official Lie
Credit: Adobe Stock

A Bold Historical Interpretation

In his speech, Mark Carney acknowledged that the Plains of Abraham were first and foremost a battlefield, but he quickly emphasized another dimension. According to him, this site also marks the beginning of Canada’s historic choice to prioritize adaptation over assimilation, partnership over domination, and collaboration over division. He argued that despite initial aspirations toward assimilation, Canada had ultimately chosen a different path—that of coexistence between two formerly hostile peoples.

The Prime Minister cited several historical moments to support his argument, including the Quebec Act of 1774, which recognized certain rights for French Catholics, and George-Étienne Cartier’s remarks about people of different races working together. He also mentioned the two Quebec referendums in which the population chose to remain part of Canada, seeing these decisions as proof that this partnership deserved to be preserved and strengthened.

There is something deeply disturbing about this desire to reinterpret history to make it more acceptable to the Canadian consciousness. Carney seems to be saying that simply wanting to rewrite the past is enough to change its reality. But the facts are stubborn. The Conquest was not a choice of collaboration; it was an imposition by force. Assimilation was not avoided; it was systematically pursued—sometimes subtly, sometimes brutally—but always with the same goal: to erase Quebec’s distinctiveness.

The Political Context of the Speech

This speech does not fall on deaf ears. It comes at a time when relations between Quebec and Ottawa are strained, when the sovereignty movement appears to be gaining momentum, and when external threats—particularly from the United States—are weighing on the entire country. Mark Carney used this address to call for Canadian unity, emphasizing that Canada is at its strongest when it stands united in the face of adversity.

The prime minister also took advantage of his visit to Quebec City to attend a cabinet retreat and meet with representatives of the provincial government. Some observers see this timing as an attempt to regain control of Quebec’s national narrative at a time when sentiments of identity are particularly strong. Others view it instead as a political blunder that risks producing the opposite effect of what was intended.

What annoys me the most is the condescension that seeps through every word Carney utters. He comes to talk to us about Canadian unity at the symbolic site of our defeat, as if we were children who need reassuring. The unity he advocates isn’t a union among equals; it’s submission disguised as partnership. We’re being asked to be grateful for what Canada has allowed us to keep, as if our language, our culture, and our identity were gifts bestowed upon us rather than hard-won achievements.

Share this post

facebook icon twitter icon linkedin icon
Copied!