COLUMN: 12.4 billion to calm the storm or feed the illusion

COLUMN: 12.4 billion to calm the storm or feed the illusion
Credit: Adobe Stock

When Experts Disagree with the Government

The DPB report estimates that the one-time payment will cost more than $3.1 billion this year. Annual increases, meanwhile, will range from $1.7 billion to $1.9 billion per year through 2031, for a total of nearly $9.2 billion. While the estimate for the one-time payment aligns with Ottawa’s projections, the estimate for the annual increases exceeds the government’s projection of 8.6 billion by 600 million. The government defended its figures in a terse press release. John Fragos, spokesperson for Finance Minister François-Philippe Champagne, stated that Ottawa was maintaining its estimate of 11.7 billion over six years, while acknowledging that it could not comment on the DPB’s methodology. A polite way of saying: we disagree, but we can’t prove they’re wrong.

This battle over numbers both fascinates and exasperates me. On one hand, there’s an independent agency doing its job rigorously. On the other, a government defending its projections without really explaining why they differ. Who should we believe? The DPB has no political incentive to inflate the numbers. The government, on the other hand, has every incentive to minimize the cost. So yes, I side with the experts. And it makes me furious to see them still playing with the numbers as if Canadians were too stupid to understand.

Share this post

facebook icon twitter icon linkedin icon
Copied!