COLUMN: Hundreds of Montrealers are shouting at Carney what the polls are whispering—don’t drag us into this war

COLUMN: Hundreds of Montrealers are shouting at Carney what the polls are whispering—don’t drag us into this war
Credit: Adobe Stock

The Hormuz Dilemma

Mark Carney asserts that Canada will not participate in the conflict. The statement is clear, measured, and reassuring. But in the same week, he announces that Canada could help ensure safe navigation through the Strait of Hormuz. And that’s where this balancing act begins to tear at the fabric of credibility.

Because the Strait of Hormuz is not a peaceful shipping lane where cargo ships carry oranges. It is the chokepoint through which one-fifth of the world’s oil passes. It is the flashpoint where Iran and the United States have been locking horns for decades. Sending Canadian ships there in the midst of an Israeli-American war against Iran is not “contributing to maritime security.” It is choosing a side while pretending to remain neutral.

The precedent no one mentions

Saturday’s protesters, however, aren’t fooled. They remember Afghanistan. They remember being told it would be a stabilization mission, not a war. One hundred fifty-eight Canadians came home in coffins. And twenty years later, the Taliban are still in power. “Stabilization” has stabilized nothing but Canadian military cemeteries.

And yet, here we are, being served the same dish all over again, with a different sauce. This time, it’s not terrorism we’re fighting—it’s Iran’s nuclear program. But the mechanics are identical: a powerful ally demanding loyalty, a prime minister seeking to show that Canada matters on the international stage, and ordinary citizens who are being asked to trust the government.

Share this post

facebook icon twitter icon linkedin icon
Copied!