COLUMN: Trump Wants to Keep His Documents — The DOJ Tells Him He Has the Right to Do So

COLUMN: Trump Wants to Keep His Documents — The DOJ Tells Him He Has the Right to Do So
Credit: Adobe Stock

The Subtle Language of a Power Play

The words chosen deserve to be read slowly. The DOJ asserts that the Presidential Records Act “exceeds the powers of Congress to the detriment of the constitutional independence and autonomy of the executive branch.” Behind the legal jargon, the meaning is crystal clear: Congress has no right to tell the president what to do with his records.

This is a statement that overturns half a century of constitutional consensus. And it wasn’t uttered by a commentator on a television set. It comes from the legal counsel of the Department of Justice—the institution supposed to uphold the law, not tear it down.

When the guardian of the law declares that the law no longer exists, who is left to defend it?

The Constitutional Argument—and Its Blind Spot

The DOJ’s argument rests on the separation of powers. Congress, it says, cannot “compel an entire branch of government to create and preserve every possible document.” It’s an argument that sounds reasonable—until you realize what it implies.

If Congress cannot require the preservation of presidential records, then no one can. The courts do not have that authority of their own. The president is not going to impose it on himself. And the National Archives, without a legal mandate, becomes a museum without a collection.

The blind spot is staggering: within this system, who ensures that those in power leave a paper trail?

Share this post

facebook icon twitter icon linkedin icon
Copied!