EDITORIAL: CBC/Radio-Canada Devours Its Own Children — The Betrayal Is Complete

EDITORIAL: CBC/Radio-Canada Devours Its Own Children — The Betrayal Is Complete
Credit: Adobe Stock

The Paradox of the Billion That Destroys What It Claims to Save

CBC/Radio-Canada’s business model is based on a fundamental contradiction that no one in Ottawa seems willing to face head-on. On the one hand, the Broadcasting Act entrusts the public broadcaster with an explicit mission: to strengthen Canadian culture, promote a diversity of voices, and support local news in underserved regions. On the other hand, in practice, CBC/Radio-Canada has gradually transformed itself into a digital machine that siphons off the same advertising revenue as private media outlets, developing online content platforms that directly compete with offerings from newspapers, private television networks, and independent news sites—all with an unbeatable structural advantage: taxpayer money as a permanent guarantee. This is not an ideological accusation. These are documented facts, observed and measured by industry insiders who have no interest in inventing a fictional threat.

Canada’s private media outlets have endured a decade of massive job losses. Postmedia, Torstar, Bell Media, and the major Quebec media groups—all have announced wave after wave of cutbacks, closures of local offices, and the elimination of reporter positions. Hundreds of experienced journalists have left the profession, not because they no longer wanted to report the news, but because business models simply could no longer afford to pay them. Against this backdrop of structural devastation, seeing CBC/Radio-Canada not only maintain its workforce thanks to public subsidies but also develop aggressive digital strategies that are eating into the very revenue streams private media outlets are desperately trying to preserve—well, that’s a slap in the face. A slap delivered with the money of the very people who read, watch, and listen to these private media outlets in crisis.

When Ottawa Turns a Blind Eye to the Fire

What makes the situation unreasonably worse is Ottawa’s chronic inaction in the face of this reality. Successive governments—both Liberal and Conservative—have continued to pour their annual billion into CBC/Radio-Canada without ever seriously questioning the impact of this funding on the private media ecosystem. Worse still: certain federal policies have simultaneously introduced tax credits and support mechanisms for private media, as if the two measures did not cancel each other out. On the one hand, public money is poured into a giant that crushes the small players. On the other, band-aids are handed out to the wounded. The absurdity of this reasoning would be laughable if it didn’t have such real consequences for real jobs, real communities, and the quality of information Canadians receive.

There is something deeply revealing about the way Ottawa continues to fund CBC/Radio-Canada at arm’s length while claiming to save private media with symbolic measures. It’s the equivalent of hosing down a fire on one side while pouring gasoline on the other—and patting ourselves on the back for taking action.

Share this post

facebook icon twitter icon linkedin icon
Copied!