When Citing the Law Becomes a Crime: Five Democratic Elected Officials Under Investigation for Citing the Uniform Code of Military Justice

When Citing the Law Becomes a Crime: Five Democratic Elected Officials Under Investigation for Citing the Uniform Code of Military Justice
Credit: Custom

What the Elected Officials Actually Said

On November 18, 2025, Senator Slotkin posted a video on her social media accounts. Six Democrats appear one after another, all with backgrounds in the military or intelligence. The message is simple, direct, and factual: “You have all taken an oath to protect and defend this Constitution,” they tell members of the armed forces and intelligence agencies. “Right now, the threats to our Constitution aren’t just coming from abroad, but from right here at home.” Then comes the key line, the one that would unleash a storm of controversy: “Our laws are clear. You can refuse illegal orders. You MUST refuse illegal orders.”

The video does not name any specific orders. It does not mention Trump by name. It simply reiterates what every service member learns during basic training. The 1969 ruling in United States v. Keenan made it clear: “Obedience to a lawful order is justified, but obedience to a manifestly unlawful order is not.” The Uniform Code of Military Justice confirms this. Members of the armed forces take an oath to the Constitution, not to the commander-in-chief or anyone else in the chain of command. These elected officials have simply reiterated this legal reality. But in Trump 2.0’s America, reminding people of the law when it displeases the president apparently amounts to high treason.

Do you know what strikes me the most? The banality of what they said. “You can refuse illegal orders.” It’s in every military training manual. It’s taught at West Point, Annapolis, and Colorado Springs. The Steady State group, which brings together more than 300 national security experts, confirmed it: these elected officials did nothing more than “restate what every officer and soldier already knows.” So why the outrage? Why the investigation? The answer is simple: because this legal truth is unwelcome. Because it suggests that certain orders might be illegal. And that, apparently, is intolerable.

The Context: Military Personnel Under Pressure

The video didn’t come out of nowhere. In November 2025, the Trump administration had deployed the National Guard in several U.S. cities, sometimes against the advice of local governors. Military strikes had been ordered against ships suspected of transporting drugs in the Caribbean and the Pacific, killing people without trial or judgment. Senator Kelly, when interviewed on Face the Nation, had expressed concern about Trump’s past statements suggesting he would be willing to use the military illegally—including his suggestions to kill the families of terrorists or, according to a former Secretary of Defense, to shoot protesters in the legs.

The six lawmakers were addressing service members whom they knew were “under enormous pressure,” as Slotkin says in the video. They reminded them of their rights and assured them of their support. “We know this is hard,” they said. “But whether you serve in the CIA, the Army, the Navy, or the Air Force, your vigilance is crucial. ” They conclude with a famous Navy motto: “Don’t give up the ship”—don’t abandon the ship. A call for courage and fidelity to principles. Nothing more. Nothing seditious. Nothing that, in any functioning democracy, should warrant a criminal investigation.

Share this post

facebook icon twitter icon linkedin icon
Copied!