ANALYSIS: The Court of Appeals Blocks Trump’s Executive Order on Mail-In Voting in 23 States

ANALYSIS: The Court of Appeals Blocks Trump’s Executive Order on Mail-In Voting in 23 States
Credit: Adobe Stock

"Premature," According to the DOJ

According to CNBC, the Department of Justice (DOJ) argued that the legal challenge was premature because the relevant federal agencies had not yet finalized the actions and policies necessary to effectively implement the executive order. If accepted, this procedural argument would have allowed for the postponement of any substantive judicial review until the contested measures were actually implemented.

The appellate court judges rejected this argument by a majority, meaning they deemed the potential harm sufficiently concrete and imminent to warrant judicial intervention even before the executive order was fully implemented.

Deadlines Deemed “Rapidly Approaching”

According to Reuters, the judges wrote that the executive order imposed “rapidly approaching” deadlines requiring states to coordinate with federal officials and comply with new voting procedures. This judicial wording explicitly acknowledges real time pressure on the election administrations of the affected states, just a few months before the November elections.

Recognizing fast-approaching deadlines as grounds for the admissibility of the lawsuit amounts to saying that the election calendar itself constitutes a legal emergency, regardless of whether federal agencies have fully finalized the implementing policies.

Saying that a lawsuit is premature does not erase an election deadline, which is never premature.

Share this post

facebook icon twitter icon linkedin icon
Copied!