Today, a cheap dinner might mean finding a supermarket deal or using up leftovers. During the Great Depression, families often had to go further, stretching small amounts of meat and finding substitutes for ingredients they couldn’t afford. But making do didn’t always mean eating badly. Even without eggs, milk, or butter, resourceful bakers could still put a fluffy chocolate cake on the table. Some of these dishes became comfort foods, while others might take a little convincing. Here are 20 surprisingly cheap meals and treats families made during the Great Depression.
1. Ritz Crackers Faked A Convincing Apple Pie
Mock apple pie was first popularized by Nabisco in 1934, but it can actually be traced back to the kitchens of 19th-century pioneers. Nabisco included the recipe on the back of a box of its Ritz Crackers during wartime rationing, and it remained there for decades. The trick is to line a pie crust with Ritz Crackers and pour over a boiled syrup of sugar, water, lemon juice, and cream of tartar. The crackers soften in the oven and resemble apples, while the lemon adds tartness.
2. City Chicken Was Pork Dressed Up As Poultry
City Chicken’s peak was in the 1930s, though there’s no actual chicken in the dish. Before the rise of factory farming in the 1940s, hens were mostly kept for their eggs, and fresh chicken was an expensive luxury reserved for Sunday dinners. Polish, Ukrainian, and other immigrant cooks in industrial cities found veal and pork scraps to be cheap and plentiful. Cubed and skewered into drumstick shapes, these cuts were then breaded, fried, and baked with gravy.
3. Water Pie Turned Tap Water Into Dessert
Water pie was a Depression-era dessert made by pouring plain old water into an unbaked pie shell, sprinkling the water with flour, sugar, vanilla, cinnamon, and dots of butter. The baker must resist the urge to stir the ingredients. Once baked, the water pie will have a silky, almost custard-like filling and a golden-brown crust. Water pie required no eggs, milk, or fresh fruit.
4. Hoover Stew Turned A President's Name Into A Joke
Herbert Hoover didn’t create Hoover Stew, but the dish named after him was certainly a dig at the president many held responsible for the nation’s financial woes. It consisted of elbow macaroni, canned tomatoes, corn or beans, and sliced hot dogs boiled together in a one-pot meal. Eaten mostly by those living in Hoovervilles, or shantytowns, the dish was a particularly mean bit of political humor cooked up in the early 1930s by folks who, figuratively speaking, had nothing left to lose. The canned tomato juice served as the dish’s simple sauce.
5. Porcupine Meatballs Doubled Dinner With Raw Rice
Porcupine meatballs are made of beef and rice, not porcupine. These meatballs got their name from the appearance of cooked rice poking out of the meatball, resembling porcupine quills. The rice absorbed moisture and expanded, stretching a pound of ground beef into a larger meal. Cooks mixed together ground beef and uncooked long-grain rice, then shaped the mixture into meatballs and baked them under a sauce made from condensed tomato soup mixed with water. By the 1930s, porcupine meatballs were a Depression-era staple.
6. Wacky Cake Rose Without Eggs, Milk Or Butter
Wacky Cake, also known as Crazy Cake, is a Depression-era cake created when eggs, butter, and milk were too expensive to use in a recipe. Instead, flour, sugar, cocoa, baking soda, and oil are mixed together, and vinegar and cold water are added. The acid in the vinegar reacts with the baking soda, releasing carbon dioxide that makes the cake rise. Wacky Cake is basically just a chemical reaction.
7. Tomato Soup Cake Hid Campbell's In A Spice Cake
Tomato soup cake replaced the milk and eggs found in other recipes with Campbell’s condensed tomato soup. The acidity in the soup reacts with the baking soda, and the pectin helps keep the cake moist, so despite the ingredient, it doesn’t taste savory. When mixed with flour, cinnamon, cloves, and nutmeg, and topped with cream cheese frosting, the final cake tastes more like a fragrant spice cake. Recipes for tomato soup cake first appeared in community cookbooks in the late 1920s. In 1940, Campbell’s released an official recipe of their own.
8. Mulligan Stew Fed Rail Camps From A Shared Pot
Hobo jungles, makeshift campsites near rail yards that dated back to the late 1800s, swelled in the 1930s with out-of-work men who traveled by train in search of employment. Hobo Stew, or Mulligan Stew, got its name from the practice of each man contributing whatever food he had managed to scrounge or beg, such as potatoes, cabbage, an onion, or scraps of meat, to a common stew pot. With just salt and pepper to season it, it was a far cry from gourmet cooking, but it beat going hungry.
9. Peanut Butter And Pickles Made A Cheap Protein Lunch
In the 1930s, peanut butter and pickles or relish sandwiches were quite popular. Peanut butter was being pushed by the USDA’s Bureau of Home Economics as an inexpensive source of protein and fat that did not have to be refrigerated. And vinegar-rich, crunchy pickles balanced the peanut butter’s stickiness and heaviness. Together, they made an inexpensive calorie bomb, ideal for schoolchildren and workers.
10. Milkorno Was The Government's Lab-Built Dinner Staple
Milkorno originated as an inexpensive but nutritionally complete food when home economist Flora Rose and colleagues at Cornell University mixed together powdered skim milk, cornmeal, and salt in February 1933. The product could be boiled into porridge or baked into loaves or slabs resembling polenta. Milkorno was intentionally bland when made in institutional kitchens so that seasoning would be left to home cooking. Milkorno lunches, costing only 7.5 cents, were served beginning in March 1933 by First Lady Eleanor Roosevelt at the White House in an effort to normalize the idea of relief foods.
11. Poor Man's Meal Fried Potatoes And Hot Dogs Into Dinner
Poor Man’s Meal was a dinner option for folks who couldn’t necessarily afford butcher meat. The dish called for diced potatoes, onions, and sliced hot dogs fried together in the same skillet, with the hot dogs adding fat and salt to the potatoes. Poor Man’s Meal was popular during the 1930s, and Depression-era survivor Clara Cannucciari revived interest in it with her online cooking series featuring recipes from her family.
12. Creamed Chipped Beef Marched From Army Camp To Kitchen Table
Creamed chipped beef on toast began life as a humble mess-hall dish, but gained popularity in the 1930s as a cheap way to fill hungry bellies. Soldiers called it “S.O.S.,” an unflattering nickname for its appearance, and as early as 1910 the dish had already been codified in a government manual for cooks. All they had to do was soak dried, salted chipped beef to rid it of some of that salt, add it to a white gravy made of flour and butter, then serve it over toast. It made its way from army barracks to family dinner tables and from there to diners around the country.
13. White House Spaghetti Boiled The Flavor Right Out
The USDA’s Bureau of Home Economics developed what became known as White House Spaghetti in 1933 as part of First Lady Eleanor Roosevelt’s 7.5-cent relief lunch program, and it was more concerned with nutrition than flavor. They boiled dried spaghetti for 20 to 25 minutes, no less, until it was mushy, and boiled sliced carrots separately. Then they combined the two with a plain white sauce of milk, flour, and butter, and baked the concoction. Hot pepper and garlic? Out of the question because they were unnecessary stimulants.
14. American Goulash Stretched Beef With A Pound Of Macaroni
American goulash, sometimes called slumgullion, is a dish that, except for its name, has nothing to do with the paprika-based stew that bears the same name in Hungary. Instead, cooks browned ground beef with onions and green peppers, and simmered it with canned tomatoes and elbow macaroni, cooking the pasta directly in the sauce. As the macaroni absorbed the juices from the meat and tomatoes, its starch also helped thicken the sauce, stretching out a small amount of beef to feed six to eight people. American goulash was a popular skillet dish among working-class households, especially in the Midwest and along the East Coast.
15. Beanie Weenie Casserole Glazed Beans Into Kids' Favorite
Hot Dog and Bean Casserole, better known as Beanie Weenie, was a popular dinner in many 1930s homes. The dish layered navy beans with sliced hot dogs, then covered them with a sauce of brown sugar, molasses, ketchup, and mustard, and baked until the franks crisped and the sauce glazed. When red meat was out of reach for many families, canned or dried beans provided a source of cheap protein, and with a sweet sauce, it was a meal even kids wanted for dinner. The casserole even inspired the canned version, still found in stores today.
16. Dandelion Greens Filled The Gap Left By Empty Cellars
Winter root cellars stood empty by early spring in the 1930s, and cooks turned to dandelion greens to ease the spring doldrums. Some historians believe this reflected a mild vitamin C deficiency, though that wasn’t a diagnosis at the time. They would gather the young dandelion greens before they flowered to avoid the bitter taste, wash them, and serve them as a salad. A dressing made from bacon fat, vinegar, sugar, and mustard was heated and poured over the greens to wilt them.
17. Corned Beef Hash Fried One Can Into A Crispy Crowd-Pleaser
A can of corned beef stretched with twice its volume in diced boiled potatoes and onions made a filling dinner for several. This economical dish uses no fresh butcher meat. Chop the tinned meat, mix with the potatoes and onions, then press into a hot skillet with lard or bacon grease to make a crispy hash. Leave undisturbed until nicely browned and crispy underneath. In the 1930s, tinned corned beef was one of the few canned meats families could count on for an affordable dinner.
18. Haluski Fed Coal Towns On Cabbage And Noodles Alone
Buttery, black peppered haluski traveled beyond Polish, Ukrainian, and Slovak immigrant families who settled in coal patches in Pennsylvania and steel towns around the Great Lakes, and into other homes in the 1930s. Cooks shredded cabbage and onions, slowly cooking them down until they caramelized in butter or bacon fat. The mixture was served heaped over wide egg noodles. Cabbage and dry pasta were inexpensive and could be stretched, making haluski a hearty, meatless meal.
19. Potato Pancakes Fried Pennies Into A Crispy Main Dish
Potatoes were a crucial ingredient in many German, Jewish, and Irish immigrant households during the 1930s when the versatile vegetable often cost less than a penny a pound. One popular dish, a potato pancake known as a latke or kartoffelpuffer depending on the culture, required grating potatoes and onions and squeezing out the excess liquid, usually with cheesecloth. Cooks then added flour and an egg, or just water, and fried the mixture in hot lard until deep golden brown. Skipping the squeezing step led to less-than-crispy pancakes.
20. Navy Bean Soup Stretched One Ham Bone Into Comfort Food
Navy bean soup was popular in Depression-era America, made with dried white beans, onion, celery, and a ham hock or pork bone that could be had for mere cents a pound. The beans were soaked overnight, then simmered slowly. The ham hock gave the soup a smoky flavor without needing butchered meat, and as the beans softened and fell apart, they thickened the soup. Navy bean soup sustained millions of families during the 1930s and was even a daily offering at the cafeteria of the U.S. Capitol.
This content was created with the help of AI.