ANALYSIS: NATO Rejects a Blockade of the Strait of Hormuz — and Trump Discovers the Limits of Intimidation Among Allies

ANALYSIS: NATO Rejects a Blockade of the Strait of Hormuz — and Trump Discovers the Limits of Intimidation Among Allies
Credit: Adobe Stock

The Transatlantic Divide Comes to Light

What is striking about this refusal is not its existence—it is its unanimity. France, Germany, the United Kingdom, and Italy—the four European pillars of NATO—have all declined. Not a single major ally agreed to deploy warships in an operation that Washington presented as a demonstration of Atlantic solidarity.

We must grasp the significance of this. NATO is an alliance founded on a simple principle: an attack against one is an attack against all. Article 5 is its DNA, its raison d’être, its glue. But an offensive naval blockade against a third country—without a UN Security Council resolution, without a prior act of aggression to cite—falls under neither Article 5 nor even Article 4. It falls under U.S. foreign policy, period.

And the Europeans have chosen to underscore this distinction with surgical precision.

The reasons behind the capitals’ silence

Berlin does not want a spike in energy prices that would deal the final blow to a German industry already in a technical recession. Paris refuses to jeopardize its diplomatic channels with Tehran—France has maintained a complex but functional relationship with Iran for decades. London, despite its special relationship with Washington, coldly calculates that the risk of escalation outweighs any strategic benefit.

And then there is the question that no one asks out loud but that everyone is thinking: why risk a war in the Persian Gulf when the war in Ukraine is already demanding naval resources, ammunition, political attention, and diplomatic capital—all of which Europe does not have in unlimited supply?

Share this post

facebook icon twitter icon linkedin icon
Copied!