ANALYSIS: OpenAI Cries "Conspiracy" — When AI Titans Turn on Each Other

ANALYSIS: OpenAI Cries "Conspiracy" — When AI Titans Turn on Each Other
Credit: Adobe Stock

A heart emoji and an indecent proposal

Court documents have revealed text message exchanges between Musk and Zuckerberg. The sequence is almost too perfect to be made up. First, Zuckerberg offers to help Musk with DOGE—the Department of Federal Budget Reduction. Musk responds with a heart emoji. Then comes the question that turns the case on its head: Musk asks Zuckerberg if he would be “open to bidding on OpenAI’s intellectual property.”

Zuckerberg suggests continuing the conversation over the phone. Which means—and every antitrust lawyer knows this—that the two men understood the rest of the conversation should leave no written trail.

What these messages prove—and what they don’t prove

For OpenAI, the evidence is damning: two direct competitors are coordinating an offensive against a third. Under U.S. antitrust law, this is potentially a violation of the Sherman Act—the equivalent of a cartel among rivals. But the legal reality is more nuanced. Discussing an acquisition is not the same as sabotaging a competitor. Proposing to bid jointly on intellectual property is not, in and of itself, illegal.

The line between aggressive competition and anti-competitive conspiracy is precisely where the legal battle of the coming months will be fought.

Share this post

facebook icon twitter icon linkedin icon
Copied!