COLUMN: Carney Whispers While Trump Threatens to Wipe Out a Civilization

COLUMN: Carney Whispers While Trump Threatens to Wipe Out a Civilization
Credit: Adobe Stock

Words That Are No Longer Threats

“An entire civilization will die tonight, never to return.” Read that sentence again. Then read it one more time. It’s not a metaphor. It’s not a negotiator’s bluff. It’s a head of state—leading the world’s largest army—announcing on social media the possibility of the annihilation of a civilization.

UN Secretary-General António Guterres was more direct than Carney: targeting Iranian civilian infrastructure would constitute a clear violation of international law. Not a “we hope that all parties”—but a clear violation. The difference between the two statements is the difference between a doctor who makes a diagnosis and a doctor who says, “Take care of yourself.”

The precedent no one wants to see

There is a word for what Trump is describing. International lawyers know this word. Historians do too. When a leader announces the destruction of an entire civilization and orders massive strikes against a sovereign country, we are no longer in the realm of coercive diplomacy. We are in the realm of a publicly articulated existential threat.

And Canada—this country that prides itself on being a pillar of multilateralism, a defender of international law, an architect of the Responsibility to Protect doctrine—that very Canada responds with “all parties.” The irony would be delicious if people weren’t dying.

Share this post

facebook icon twitter icon linkedin icon
Copied!