ANALYSIS: Trump Threatens to Level Iranian Power Plants — and International Law Can’t Do Anything About It

ANALYSIS: Trump Threatens to Level Iranian Power Plants — and International Law Can’t Do Anything About It
Credit: Adobe Stock

The Fundamental Distinction Between Civilian and Military

International humanitarian law is based on a principle so simple that even a ten-year-old could understand it: civilians must not be targeted. And yet, it is precisely this principle that the major powers have been circumventing for decades.

Article 52 of Additional Protocol I to the Geneva Conventions establishes a red line that is, in theory, inviolable. Civilian objects—hospitals, schools, power plants, bridges—cannot be targeted. Period. No nuances. No apparent exceptions. A power plant that supplies electricity to millions of households is a civilian object.

But the law has its loopholes. And military lawyers know them by heart.

The “dual-use” loophole

The same convention opens a door that military leaders around the world have learned to force open: a civilian object becomes a legitimate military target if it “effectively contributes to military action” and if its destruction offers “a specific military advantage.” Two cumulative conditions. Two conditions vague enough to justify just about anything.

Does a power plant supply civilian hospitals? Certainly. But it also supplies military bases, air defense systems, and command centers. Does a bridge allow ambulances to pass? Yes. But it also allows military convoys to move. International humanitarian law recognizes this duality—and that is precisely where it all falls apart.

The United States used this logic in Iraq in 1991, in Serbia in 1999, and in Libya in 2011. Each time, civilian infrastructure was struck in the name of “dual use.” Each time, legal experts approved the strikes before they were carried out. International law did not prevent a single one of these bombings.

Share this post

facebook icon twitter icon linkedin icon
Copied!