ANALYSIS: France Did Not Break NATO’s Back—It Revealed That It Was Already Fractured

ANALYSIS: France Did Not Break NATO’s Back—It Revealed That It Was Already Fractured
Credit: Adobe Stock

The Original Sin: Talking to Everyone

French diplomacy is seen as problematic because it refuses to choose between talking to the Ukrainians and talking to the Russians. In Washington in 2026, this position is considered treason. In the rest of the world, it’s called diplomacy.

In the eyes of the American right, Emmanuel Macron has committed a series of unforgivable crimes. He kept channels of communication open. He insisted on the need for a European security architecture that does not depend exclusively on the goodwill of the occupant of the White House. He proposed security guarantees for Ukraine that do not necessarily require immediate NATO membership.

In short, he practiced diplomacy. And in the toxic atmosphere of current American foreign policy, diplomacy has become synonymous with capitulation.

The Real Issue: European Strategic Autonomy

The crux of the matter is not what Macron says about Russia or Ukraine. The crux of the matter is what he says about Europe. Since his 2017 speech at the Sorbonne—a message he has reiterated with increasing intensity—the French president has been promoting a concept that terrifies Washington: European strategic autonomy.

Put simply: Europeans capable of defending themselves without American permission. Europeans who buy European weapons rather than F-35s. Europeans who define their own security interests without consulting the Pentagon at every turn.

For the U.S. military-industrial complex, this is an existential threat. For RedState and the Trumpist right, it is an affront. For anyone who looks at the situation with intellectual honesty, it is the logical consequence of four years in which Washington treated its European allies as ungrateful vassals rather than as sovereign partners.

Share this post

facebook icon twitter icon linkedin icon
Copied!