ANALYSIS: Trump, 9/11, and the Art of Rewriting History on Camera: He Says, “I Knew It”

ANALYSIS: Trump, 9/11, and the Art of Rewriting History on Camera: He Says, “I Knew It”
Credit: Adobe Stock

"The America We Deserve," published in January 2000

Trump is referring to his book The America We Deserve, published in January 2000. The book exists. The mention of bin Laden exists. Let’s check. In the chapter on foreign policy, Trump writes that bin Laden poses a threat and that the United States should take terrorism more seriously. He also mentions the first attack on the World Trade Center in 1993.

But saying that someone is a threat is not the same as predicting a specific attack on a specific building on a specific date. In 2000, U.S. intelligence agencies—the FBI, the CIA—and several foreign governments knew that bin Laden was planning a major attack. The 9/11 Commission Report documented this over 585 pages. Trump was not an isolated prophet crying out in the wilderness. He was a New York real estate developer who was simply repeating what everyone else was saying.

The Mechanics of Retrospective Prophecy

This is a cognitive bias that has been documented for decades. Psychologists call it the hindsight bias—the human tendency to believe, after an event has occurred, that we had predicted it. We all do it. But we don’t all do it in front of cameras, as president, during an international crisis, regarding the worst terrorist attack in our country’s history.

The difference between an ordinary citizen saying “I saw this coming” at a Christmas dinner and a commander-in-chief declaring it at an official press conference is the complete collapse of the distinction between private narcissism and public responsibility.

Share this post

facebook icon twitter icon linkedin icon
Copied!