ANALYSIS: The Netherlands and Iceland Join the Legal Battle Against Israel at The Hague

ANALYSIS: The Netherlands and Iceland Join the Legal Battle Against Israel at The Hague
Credit: Adobe Stock

How South Africa Broke the Ice

It all began on December 29, 2023, when the Republic of South Africa filed a formal complaint with the International Court of Justice, accusing Israel of violating the 1948 Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide in the context of its military operations in Gaza. Pretoria’s decision was no accident. South Africa carries within its national DNA the memory of apartheid, of trampled rights, and of the international solidarity that ultimately triumphed. The ANC government carefully crafted every word of its petition, mobilized its best legal experts, and built a case that immediately forced the world to take notice. In January 2024, the ICJ issued a historic provisional order, directing Israel to take all measures within its power to prevent acts that could constitute genocide. Israel rejected this characterization. But the proceedings continued.

Since then, several states have joined the proceedings as interveners—a legal mechanism provided for by the ICJ Statute that allows third parties to submit observations on questions of law without being principal parties to the dispute. This mechanism is crucial: it allows us to gauge in real time the shifting stance of the international community, to see which countries choose to align themselves with the cause and which remain on the sidelines. The list of intervenors has become a diplomatic barometer of formidable precision. Every new name added to it exerts additional pressure—legal, political, and moral.

South Africa ignited a spark that its critics thought they could quickly extinguish. A year later, this legal fire has spread to Central and Northern Europe. Those who had bet on the impotence of international institutions may be beginning to reconsider.

The Third-Party Intervention Mechanism: What It Means in Practice

Third-party intervention before the ICJ, provided for in Article 62 of the Court’s Statute, is not an empty symbolic gesture. An intervening State submits a statement of intervention in which it sets forth its interpretation of the issues of international law at stake. This statement becomes part of the case file, read and weighed by the judges. It influences the Court’s legal reasoning. It constitutes a source of interpretation that the main parties may cite or refute. Above all, it compels the intervening State to publicly take a stance—before the world’s highest court—on the acts in question. This is no longer a tweet, a press release, or a symbolic resolution passed by the UN General Assembly. It is a solemn legal act, set forth in the language of international law.

Share this post

facebook icon twitter icon linkedin icon
Copied!