ANALYSIS: When Washington Fights the Wrong War — The Iranian Gamble That Is Shaking Up the Global Oil Market

ANALYSIS: When Washington Fights the Wrong War — The Iranian Gamble That Is Shaking Up the Global Oil Market
Credit: Adobe Stock

The Return of a Strategy That Had Already Shown Its Limitations

We must look back at Trump’s first term to understand what is at stake today. Between 2018 and 2021, the Trump administration had already implemented its policy of maximum pressure against Iran, notably by unilaterally withdrawing from the 2015 nuclear agreement—the JCPOA—and reimposing devastating economic sanctions. The result? The Iranian economy did indeed suffer. The Iranian rial collapsed. The population paid a considerable human price. But the regime held firm. More than that: Iran accelerated its uranium enrichment program, increasing its stockpiles of fissile material to levels never before reached. Maximum pressure had not broken Tehran. It had hardened it.

The second term follows the same script, but within a radically transformed regional context. The war in Gaza, triggered by Hamas’s attacks in October 2023, has fundamentally reshaped the balance of power in the Middle East. Iran is now playing multiple roles simultaneously: its support for Hamas, its ties to the Lebanese Hezbollah, its connections with the Houthis in Yemen, and its presence in Syria and Iraq. This network of proxies gives it a capacity for disruption and retaliation that the Trump administration, according to its own internal sources, severely underestimated. Striking Iran directly—or threatening to do so—no longer means merely risking a direct Iranian response. It potentially means igniting multiple fronts simultaneously in a region already ablaze.

The Revolutionary Guards: A Variable Poorly Factored into the Equation

One of the most troubling blind spots in this miscalculation concerns the role of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps—the Pasdaran. This elite Iranian force, which controls not only a significant portion of the military but also entire sectors of the country’s economy, has long viewed confrontation with the United States as a structural reality, not as a one-off crisis to be managed. The Pasdaran do not think in terms of quarters or election cycles. They think in terms of decades, ideology, and the survival of the system. For them, every U.S. escalation is an opportunity to strengthen their internal grip on power. Analysts who have been warning about this dynamic for years have clearly not been heard loudly enough in Washington’s decision-making circles. The result, today, is evident in the admissions made by these anonymous U.S. sources to the Middle East Monitor.

“Maximum pressure,” as a strategy, is based on an economic premise—that any rational actor will yield when faced with sufficient pain. But Iran is not an economic actor. It is an ideological actor. And when it comes to ideology, economics does not always win out.

Share this post

facebook icon twitter icon linkedin icon
Copied!