OPINION: Sam Altman Defends AI’s Colossal Appetite and Mocks Musk’s Space Project

OPINION: Sam Altman Defends AI’s Colossal Appetite and Mocks Musk’s Space Project
Credit: Adobe Stock

An unprecedented demand for energy in the history of digital technology

Let’s talk facts. No assumptions, no alarmist projections—just documented facts. Training a single large language model like GPT-4 consumes as much electricity as hundreds of American households use in a year. The International Energy Agency has reported that global data center electricity consumption could double by 2026, driven largely by the explosive growth of generative artificial intelligence. Microsoft, a strategic partner of OpenAI, has seen its water consumption skyrocket in certain regions to cool its servers. Google has admitted that its climate goals are being undermined by the growth of its AI services. These figures are not fabrications by environmental activists. They are official data, published by the companies themselves—sometimes in tiny print at the bottom of the page in their annual reports.

What Altman is arguing, then, is this: this consumption is legitimate because the benefits of AI justify it. The argument isn’t without merit. AI accelerates medical research, optimizes energy systems, helps design more efficient batteries, and contributes to modeling climate change. There’s an irony in the fact that the technology that consumes the most could also be the one that helps us consume less. But this irony isn’t enough to settle the debate. On the contrary, it opens it up.

Water, rare earth elements, and sacrificed territories

Electricity is only the tip of the iceberg. Data centers also consume millions of liters of water for cooling. In regions already facing water stress, the construction of giant data centers raises profound questions of equity. While farmers struggle to secure water rights, servers running chatbots consume millions of liters of water each month. We must also address the rare earth metals needed to manufacture chips, GPUs, and the hardware infrastructure that supports AI—materials extracted under often disastrous conditions in countries of the Global South, at a human and environmental cost that no one in Silicon Valley is willing to face head-on. Sam Altman defends his industry’s consumption of resources. Fine. But does he also defend the conditions under which these resources are obtained? The question deserves a clear answer.

There is something viscerally disturbing about the idea that men who present themselves as the saviors of humanity are building their empire on materials extracted at the cost of blood, in Congolese or Bolivian mines, by workers who will never see a ChatGPT in their lifetime. The AI of the future rests on the shoulders of the present. And those shoulders—they’re bleeding.

Share this post

facebook icon twitter icon linkedin icon
Copied!