OPINION: The “Never Trump” camp has been sounding the alarm for years—and the silence in response is deafening

OPINION: The “Never Trump” camp has been sounding the alarm for years—and the silence in response is deafening
Credit: Adobe Stock

Profiles That Defy Stereotypes

The term “Never Trump” is often used as an insult in pro-Trump circles—a way to label traitors, out-of-touch elitists, and conservatives who don’t understand the real America. This caricature deserves to be deconstructed, because it is both false and dangerously convenient for those who want to stifle criticism. Liz Cheney has never been a moderate. She opposed same-sex marriage and voted with Trump in the overwhelming majority of cases—until January 6, 2021, the date that changed everything for her. Miles Taylor, former chief of staff at the Department of Homeland Security under Trump, spent years working for the administration before publicly testifying about the internal chaos. John Bolton, one of the most formidable hawks in American foreign policy, served as national security adviser before describing in his memoirs a president who does not understand the basic fundamentals of governance.

What all these figures have in common is precisely what makes their warnings so impossible to ignore without bad faith: they are not speaking from the outside. They are speaking from the inside. They have seen the system operate—or rather, malfunction—with their own eyes. And what they saw convinced them that a second Trump administration would pose a danger of a qualitatively different nature from any normal political transition.

Warnings That Proved Correct

This is where the story gets uncomfortable. Let’s look at the facts with the detachment they deserve. In 2016, the Never Trumps warned that Trump would treat democratic institutions as obstacles rather than safeguards. In 2020, they warned that he would not respect an election result that went against him. In January 2021, their worst-case scenario played out on screens around the world, as Trump supporters stormed the U.S. Capitol, sincerely believing that the election had been stolen from him—a conviction fueled and amplified by Trump himself for weeks. And since Trump’s return to power in 2025, those same voices have continued to point out, step by step, the signs of an authoritarian drift that follows the playbook they had written years in advance.

I want to pause here for a second. Because if you’re reading this in the United States, in Quebec, in France, in Belgium—if you’re someone who’s been observing American politics from the outside—you may be feeling a sense of weariness that I understand perfectly. We’ve been hearing about this for so long. It seems so repetitive. And yet. It’s not the repetition of a warning that makes the danger any less real. On the contrary, it’s a sign that we haven’t acted yet.

Share this post

facebook icon twitter icon linkedin icon
Copied!