Europe Deploys Troops to Greenland: When NATO Must Defend Itself Against Its Own Founder

Europe Deploys Troops to Greenland: When NATO Must Defend Itself Against Its Own Founder
Credit: Adobe Stock

Modest Forces, a Colossal Message

The numbers are modest, almost laughable compared to U.S. military might. Fifteen French mountain infantry soldiers, accustomed to extreme conditions. Thirteen German soldiers forming a Bundeswehr reconnaissance team. A few Swedish, Norwegian, British, and Dutch officers. In total, perhaps fifty people. Facing off against the U.S. Army’s 1.3 million active-duty soldiers. It’s David versus Goliath. Except that David doesn’t even have a slingshot. He has only his dignity. And a message to convey: Europe will not let one ally devour another.

Danish Defense Minister Troels Lund Poulsen was clear about the intentions behind this operation, dubbed “Arctic Endurance.” The goal is to “establish a more permanent military presence with a greater Danish contribution” on and around the island. The 2026 exercises will include the protection of critical infrastructure, assistance to local authorities, the deployment of fighter jets, and naval operations. Denmark wants to prove to Washington that it takes Arctic security seriously. That Trump’s derisive remarks about “dog sleds” supposedly being Greenland’s only defense are false. That Europe is capable of protecting its territories. Even though, deep down, everyone knows that it’s not really Russia or China that we’re trying to deter today.

Do you realize how absurd this situation is? French and German soldiers—who were killing each other 80 years ago—are now standing side by side on the Arctic ice to protect a Danish territory against… the Americans. The very same Americans who liberated Europe in 1944. The very same ones who rebuilt the continent with the Marshall Plan. The very same Americans who guaranteed our security during the Cold War. It’s as if your best childhood friend—the one who saved your life—suddenly turned against you and threatened to take your home. By force, if necessary. How are we supposed to come to terms with that?

Article 5 Put to the Test of the Unthinkable

Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty is the very heart of NATO. An attack against one member is an attack against all. It is this guarantee that has maintained peace in Europe since 1949. But what happens when the potential attacker is the alliance’s most powerful member? Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen put it bluntly: “If the United States decides to launch a military attack on another NATO country, everything comes to a halt. Including our NATO and, therefore, the security that has existed since the end of World War II.” Everything comes to a halt. Eight decades of peace. Vanished.

Experts in international law are divided on the issue. Michael Schmitt, a professor of international law at the University of Reading, notes that Article 5 simply did not anticipate this scenario. How can unanimous collective defense be activated when the aggressor has a veto? U.S. Senator Chris Murphy was categorical: NATO countries would “of course” have an obligation to defend Greenland against the United States. “That’s what Article 5 says. Article 5 did not anticipate that the invading country would be a NATO member,” he said. But there is a chasm between legal theory and the reality of a military confrontation with Washington—a chasm that no one wants to cross.

Share this post

facebook icon twitter icon linkedin icon
Copied!