When you see an ancient artifact in a museum, you usually trust that someone has checked whether it’s real. But some of history’s most celebrated discoveries earned expert approval without being ancient at all. Forged documents helped rulers claim power, while fake relics took pride of place in museum collections. Even when doubts surfaced, respected scholars sometimes spent their careers defending the deception rather than admitting they’d been fooled. Here are 20 famous forgeries that deceived experts for decades, and sometimes much longer.
1. Piltdown Man Convinced Britain It Had Found The Missing Link
In 1912, amateur British archaeologist Charles Dawson announced a jawbone and partial skull find in Sussex, England, that he claimed was the missing link between apes and humans. The British Museum’s keeper of geology, Arthur Smith Woodward, agreed and named the fossil Eoanthropus dawsoni. It wasn’t until 1953 that researcher Kenneth Oakley, using fluorine testing and chemical staining analysis, figured out the truth: Dawson had merely attached a filed and chemically stained orangutan jaw to a human skull. British science fell for the Piltdown Man hoax for 41 years! And, according to recent research, Dawson likely worked alone to pull off the scam.
2. The Flora Bust Was Sold To Berlin As A Lost Leonardo Da Vinci
Believed to be the work of none other than Leonardo da Vinci, a bust of the goddess Flora cost 185,000 Goldmarks back in 1909 when Wilhelm von Bode, director of Berlin’s Kaiser Friedrich Museum, bought it. The sculpture in fact dates from 1846, when British sculptor Richard Cockle Lucas created it as a wax bust intended to be a period piece, and his son later swore under oath that it was made of candle wax filled with crumpled-up newspaper. Dealers, not Lucas, passed the bust off as a Renaissance masterpiece. Bode, however, believed the bust to be by Leonardo until his death. Only in 2021 was the bust finally radiocarbon tested, confirming the 19th-century date.
3. The Protocols Of The Elders Of Zion Was Secret Police Propaganda Dressed As Fact
Mathieu Golovinski, an agent of the Russian secret police known as the Okhrana, wrote the Protocols of the Elders of Zion, purported minutes of a Jewish plot to take over the world, around 1902. The Russian newspaper Znamya published them in 1903. The document, plagiarized from an 1864 French political satire that didn’t mention Jewish people, was intended to make them scapegoats and deflect attention from Tsar Nicholas II. Industrialist Henry Ford and The Times of London believed them genuine until The Times journalist Philip Graves debunked the Protocols in 1921, with side-by-side comparisons to the original French work. It took nearly two decades to undo Golovinski’s damage.
4. The Donation Of Constantine Gave The Pope Supreme Power For 600 Years
Sometime in the 8th century, officials working in the papal chancery wrote a document, known as the Donation of Constantine, which claimed that Constantine I, Roman emperor, had granted Pope Sylvester I control of Rome and all the lands of the Western Roman Empire in exchange for healing him of his leprosy. Medieval popes used the Donation of Constantine to justify papal power over secular rulers for centuries. In 1440, Lorenzo Valla, an Italian scholar, exposed the Donation of Constantine as a forgery. Valla pointed out anachronisms in the Latin used, such as feudum, meaning fief, which could not possibly have been used during Constantine’s time. His identification of the Donation as a forgery exposed the deception perpetrated for more than 600 years and laid the foundation for modern textual criticism, the practice of using textual evidence to expose forgeries.
5. Thomas Chatterton Invented A Medieval Monk Poet At Age Fifteen
In 1768, 15-year-old clerk Thomas Chatterton started writing poems supposedly penned by a 15th-century monk, Thomas Rowley, and purportedly discovered by Chatterton in an old church chest in Bristol, England. Chatterton took his own life with poison in London in 1770, when he was only 17, years before scholars Thomas Warton and Edmond Malone proved that Chatterton’s “medieval” language was merely 18th-century English with archaic spellings. Controversy over the authenticity of the Rowley poems continued into the 19th century. Despite his young age and short life, Chatterton has been called a forerunner of the Romantic movement and is considered to have had a profound influence on later Romantic poets such as Wordsworth, Keats and Shelley.
6. The Met's Etruscan Warriors Stood As Masterpieces For Four Decades
Perhaps the biggest whopper occurred at the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York, where three giant terracotta warrior statues were put on display in 1933 as 5th-century-BC Etruscan masterpieces. Curator Gisela Richter championed their authenticity for years after the Met bought them from an Italian art dealer around 1920. Finally, in 1960, curator Joseph Noble noticed that manganese dioxide was used to make the glaze, and the ancient Etruscans never used it. The following year, Italian sculptor Alfredo Fioravanti confessed that he and a family of dealers had built the statues themselves around 1915. It was the museum’s first public admission that major pieces on display were modern fakes.
7. The Kensington Runestone Rewrote America's Viking History
A 200-pound stone slab that a Swedish immigrant named Olof Ohman said he had dug up in November 1898 on his farm near Kensington, Minnesota, bears runes purporting to tell of Scandinavian explorers who died there in 1362. Although Scandinavian linguists almost immediately pointed out features of the stone’s language that reflected a 19th-century Swedish dialect, Norwegian-American historian Hjalmar Holand purchased the stone and for 50 years touted its authenticity. Even the Minnesota Historical Society pronounced it genuine in 1910. Eventually, however, analysis of the chisel marks and language implicated Ohman himself, along with a neighbor, Sven Fogelblad, as the stone’s likely carvers.
8. James Macpherson Gave Scotland An Epic To Rival Homer
James Macpherson began publishing his supposed translations of ancient Gaelic poems in 1760, with Fingal and Temora following over the next few years, claiming they were written by the legendary 3rd-century blind bard Ossian. The poems inspired Thomas Jefferson and Goethe, among others. But the English writer Samuel Johnson doubted their authenticity, and dared Macpherson to produce the original manuscripts. He declined. In 1805, 45 years later, a committee of the Highland Society finally settled the authenticity issue. Macpherson had woven genuine fragments of Gaelic oral poetry into an elaborate epic of his own imagination.
9. The Zeno Map Sent Explorers Searching For An Island That Never Existed
Published in 1558 by Venetian nobleman Nicolò Zeno the Younger, the Zeno map purported to chart lands in the North Atlantic that Zeno’s ancestors had supposedly discovered in 1390. The islands of Frisland and Estotiland became quite popular with mapmakers, appearing in the world atlases of the likes of Gerardus Mercator and Abraham Ortelius, and English explorer Martin Frobisher purportedly spent years searching for Frisland. But Zeno’s islands didn’t exist, as mid-19th-century analysis revealed that Zeno’s map was plagiarized from a previous map, with the addition of fictitious islands to aggrandize the family name. This little deception fooled explorers and cartographers for over 300 years.
10. Drake's Plate Of Brass Fooled A Historian Who Went Looking For It
In 1579, English explorer Sir Francis Drake is said to have claimed California for Queen Elizabeth I. In 1936, a brass plate proclaiming as such was reportedly found near San Francisco Bay, and it stayed in textbooks for decades. But it took until 1977 for research at Oxford University and Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory to reveal that the plate was made of modern brass and had been cut using modern tools. It wasn’t until 2003 that researchers linked the plate to a historical fraternity, E Clampus Vitus, and determined that the plate was a prank. Herbert Bolton, who was the director of the Bancroft Library at the University of California, Berkeley, had challenged his students to find the brass plate, so it is thought that they forged the artifact knowing that he would validate it as genuine.
11. Thomas James Wise Used His Own Authority To Sell Fake First Editions
Thomas James Wise fooled the book world for more than 40 years, from the late 1880s until 1934. During that time, Wise secretly created more than 50 fake “rare first editions” (pamphlets) of the works of Alfred Tennyson, Elizabeth Barrett Browning, and others, complete with fictitious histories. He sold many of these books to collectors, and even fooled the British Museum into buying some of his fakes. Wise’s forgeries were eventually exposed by paper analysis: John Carter and Graham Pollard, book dealers, showed that the paper used in the pamphlets Wise claimed as rare first editions included wood pulp and esparto grass, which were not introduced until decades after the claimed dates of printing. Wise was president of the Bibliographical Society at one point, which is the Society that exists to prevent this sort of thing!
12. The Calaveras Skull Turned A Miners' Prank Into Scientific Fact
In 1866, miners working a mine shaft near Calaveras County, California, claimed to have excavated a human skull from 130 feet beneath a layer of ancient lava. The geologist Josiah Whitney, who was a professor at Harvard at the time, and several other scientists concluded that the discovery meant that people had been living in North America for more than a million years. The miners later admitted to planting a recently excavated Native American skull as a prank to fool Whitney, though Whitney maintained the authenticity of the “Calaveras Skull” until his death in 1896. It wasn’t until 1907 that Aleš Hrdlička, an anthropologist at the Smithsonian Institution, showed through chemical and physical analysis that the skull was relatively recent in origin.
13. The Walam Olum Passed Off One Man's Invention As A Native Epic
In 1836, Constantine Samuel Rafinesque, a French-American naturalist, published a work from Philadelphia, claiming that it was an epic of the migration of the Lenape, or Delaware, people. He said it had been recorded on wooden sticks by a doctor who had given them to Rafinesque in 1820. The Indiana Historical Society published a scholarly edition of the Walam Olum in 1954. In 1994, anthropologist David Oestreicher examined Rafinesque’s manuscript drafts and showed that Rafinesque had first written the story in English and then clumsily translated it into Lenape with the help of dictionaries put together by Christian missionaries. The Delaware Tribe removed its support for the Walam Olum in 1997, after the fraud had stood for 161 years.
14. The Davenport Tablets Built A Case For A Lost Race In Iowa
In 1877, Reverend Jacob Gass, a Swiss-born Lutheran minister and amateur archaeologist, claimed to have found slate tablets bearing Hebrew and Phoenician-like writing at a burial mound near Davenport, Iowa. The Davenport Academy of Natural Sciences interpreted the tablets as evidence for an ancient, lost “Mound Builder” race, but in 1885, Smithsonian ethnologist Cyrus Thomas questioned that conclusion. Decades later, Iowa State Archaeologist Marshall McKusick conclusively demonstrated that the “ancient” tablets were actually local, 19th-century roof tiles with phony markings, and that the forgeries were the work of jealous members of the Davenport Academy, hoping to embarrass Gass.
15. The Bat Creek Stone Hid A Desperate Fieldworker's Secret
In 1889, John Emmert, a fieldworker for the Smithsonian Institution, found an inscribed stone in a burial mound near Bat Creek, Tennessee. In 1894, Cyrus Thomas of the Smithsonian Institution published a report identifying the inscription as a Cherokee artifact. Then in 1970, Cyrus Gordon, a scholar, claimed that the inscription was actually ancient Hebrew and that it read “for Judea.” Finally, in 1991, archaeologists Robert Mainfort and Mary Kwas identified the hoax as having been perpetrated by Emmert himself using an 1870 Freemasonry handbook as a reference. Apparently, Emmert was hoping to impress his employers. Unfortunately for him, he was caught 102 years later. Also unfortunately for him, he had been facing dismissal for excessive drinking back in 1889, when he planted the hoax.
16. The Lead Cross Of Glastonbury Manufactured King Arthur's Grave
In 1191, monks at Glastonbury Abbey in England claimed to have discovered the grave of King Arthur and Queen Guinevere. The monks said that a lead cross above the graves read: “Here lies buried the renowned King Arthur in the Isle of Avalon.” The chronicler Gerald of Wales wrote of the discovery. Historians surmise that the monks may have fabricated the discovery after a fire destroyed the abbey in 1184 in order to reap the monetary benefits that would come from pilgrims, and possibly get aid from King Richard I. After more than 400 years of belief, it was later revealed that the script on the cross was more in line with that used in the 12th century, and not during the time in 6th century Britain when King Arthur supposedly lived.
17. The Privilegium Maius Invented Austria's Archduke Title
Forged documents, known as the Privilegium Maius, commissioned by Rudolf IV, Duke of Austria, in 1358, purported to show that Austria’s rulers had received the title “Palatine Archduke” directly from Emperor Frederick Barbarossa two centuries earlier. When Charles IV learned that the scholar Petrarch had his doubts about the authenticity of the documents, the Holy Roman Emperor denied them. Nonetheless, in 1453 Frederick III, himself a Habsburg and Holy Roman Emperor, declared them to be in force as law. Not until 1852 was the hoax finally exposed when Wilhelm Wattenbach, a German historian, proved using textual analysis that the documents were in fact forgeries. The deception thus lasted 494 years. The title “Archduke of Austria” proved to be very important for the Habsburgs and shaped their identity for generations.
18. Flint Jack Sold Victorian Museums Thousands Of Fake Stone Tools
In 1862, Edward Simpson, better known as “Flint Jack,” was exposed as having created hundreds of fake “prehistoric” stone tools after antiquarians recognized his distinctive knapping style. Rather than face the music, however, the Yorkshire craftsman offered to demonstrate how he’d deceived archaeologists and museums by knapping his own convincing-looking “prehistoric” flint tools in front of London antiquarians. Simpson was far from the only person faking archaeological artifacts in Victorian Britain, but few matched his output. Starting in the 1840s and continuing for the next two decades, he sold thousands of mud- and tea-aged fake flint axes and arrowheads to archaeology enthusiasts, local museums, and even the Geological Society of London. His admission helped launch experimental archaeology, as he toured scientific societies demonstrating his craft.
19. The Glozel Artifacts Turned A Farm Field Into A Scholarly War
Émile Fradin, a 17-year-old French farmer, claimed that in March 1924 he unearthed an extraordinary trove while plowing a field at Glozel, near Vichy: clay tablets covered in an unknown script, along with bone engravings and stone tools. The find outraged many members of the French scholarly establishment when noted archaeologist Salomon Reinach proclaimed Glozel to be the Neolithic birthplace of Western writing. The ensuing battle between skeptics and believers was bitter and long, with an international commission of scholars declaring the whole affair a fraud in 1927. Modern glass and twine had been mixed in with the clay. But then thermoluminescence testing in 1974 indicated that the Glozel artifacts were, in fact, genuinely old, and the controversy flared up again. Eventually, a series of investigations carried out for the French government between 1983 and 1995 determined that Fradin’s discovery site was actually a medieval tile kiln and that Fradin himself was guilty of planting crude modern forgeries.
20. The Letters Of Phalaris Fooled Scholars For Nearly 2,000 Years
Phalaris was a tyrant who lived in the Sicilian city of Agrigentum in the 6th century BC. For centuries, Europeans revered 148 Greek letters written by Phalaris as an invaluable historical source. In 1695, Charles Boyle, an editor at Oxford, published a prestigious edition of these letters, believing them to be genuine. Four years later, Richard Bentley, the master of Trinity College, Cambridge, demonstrated that they were forgeries. They were written in the wrong dialect of Greek, mentioned coins and towns that did not exist in the days of Phalaris, and were really the work of an anonymous sophist writing centuries after his death. In unraveling this 2,000-year-old con, Bentley helped establish the modern discipline of classical philology.
This content was created with the help of AI.