Old-fashioned toys might seem like a sweet reminder of simpler childhoods, but a closer look can make you wonder what adults were thinking. Some were unsettling to look at, while others put real hazards into little hands. Children could even get working miniature guillotines to behead their paper dolls, which makes a noisy toy seem like a pretty reasonable gift. Not everything was intended to frighten, of course, and that’s part of what makes these playthings so strange. Here are 20 creepy toys children once played with.
1. A.C. Gilbert's Atomic Energy Lab Put Real Uranium Ore In Kids' Bedrooms
In 1950, the A.C. Gilbert Company, owned by Olympic gold medalist and American inventor Alfred Carlton Gilbert, introduced the U-238 Atomic Energy Lab, a science kit that included actual samples of radioactive uranium ore along with a host of instruments, including a Geiger counter, cloud chamber, and a spinthariscope, a device for viewing radioactive decay. Boys could use these instruments to conduct their own experiments. However, the Atomic Energy Lab was too expensive and was discontinued within about a year.
2. The Toy Guillotine That Let Children Reenact France's Reign Of Terror
France’s toy makers of the early 1790s made working versions of the guillotine, two-foot-high models with a sliding blade attached to a string that could be dropped over paper dolls or little figurines. Catharina Elisabeth Goethe (mother of the writer Johann Wolfgang von Goethe) refused to purchase one of these sinister playthings, dubbing it an “infamous implement of murder.” Toy guillotines were sold in France for over a century after the Reign of Terror.
3. The Austin Magic Pistol Fired With A Real Gas Explosion
The Austin Magic Pistol was a toy gun made in the late 1940s by Michigan’s Austin Manufacturing Company. It looked a lot like the ray guns in science fiction movies of the era. When a kid mixed water and “magic crystals” (calcium carbide) in the toy’s reservoir, it created flammable acetylene gas. When the trigger was squeezed, a spark ignited the gas, firing a plastic ball and producing a flash and a pop. Sales quickly dropped, and at least one state banned it after some little gunners suffered burns when water or sweat on their fingers ignited the gas prematurely. The Magic Pistol’s life was brief, lasting just a few years.
4. Edison's Phonograph Doll Gave Children A Screeching Mechanical Voice
The first talking doll was released in 1890. Inside the doll’s tin body was a hand-cranked phonograph invented by Thomas Edison. Edison’s Phonograph Toy Manufacturing Company recorded nursery rhymes by having their workers scream into the recording horn, engraving the words onto fragile wax cylinders. When cranked, a tiny stylus would scratch along the cylinder, playing back distorted, raspy voices. The cylinders wore out quickly, so the doll was discontinued only weeks after being released. Edison later admitted that “the voices of the little monsters were exceedingly unpleasant to hear.”
5. Charlie McCarthy's Clacking Jaw Built The Creepy Dummy Archetype
The 18-inch Charlie McCarthy doll, produced by the Effanbee Doll Company in 1938 and based on NBC ventriloquist Edgar Bergen’s nationally renowned radio star of the same name, was dressed in a tuxedo and top hat, and sported a glass monocle. A pull-string located behind the toy’s neck moved its wooden jaw up and down, with a loud clack, no less. His unblinking glass eye and fixed smirk only added to the creepy ventriloquist-dummy look, and he remains in Americans’ minds to this day as the classic creepy-dummy archetype.
6. Carl Bergner's Three-Faced Doll Hid Two Expressions Under Its Bonnet
Carl Bergner, a German dollmaker in Sonneberg, created a three-faced bisque porcelain doll head ca. 1890. The expressions of the faces are sleeping, weeping (with molded-in tears), and smiling. Only one of the expressions could be seen at a time, as the head was covered with a bonnet made of cardboard and fabric. The doll’s expression could be changed quickly from sleeping to weeping to smiling by turning a small brass knob located at the top of the head. This turned a hidden socket inside the head.
7. Frozen Charlotte Dolls Were Named For A Girl Who Froze To Death
From the 1850s on, German factories turned out jointless porcelain dolls that Americans called “Frozen Charlotte” dolls, after a morbid folk ballad. “Fair Charlotte,” based on an 1841 poem by American writer Elizabeth Oakes Smith, tells of a vain girl who dies of exposure because she refuses to put on a coat before going to a dance. Children sometimes bathed and wrapped the pale, stiff figures or even “buried” them in play coffins. These inexpensive dolls could be purchased for as little as a penny.
8. The Gilbert Kaster Kit Handed Boys A 621-Degree Lead Furnace
The A.C. Gilbert Company, owned by Alfred Carlton Gilbert, marketed a home metal-casting kit during the Great Depression known as the Kaster Kit. The kit included a small electric furnace that plugged into a standard outlet, iron molds, and bars of lead. Once the lead bars were heated to 621 degrees Fahrenheit in the furnace, children could use the kit to pour lead soldiers, cannons, trains, and other items. Ads touted that children could “make lead soldiers by the dozen” with the kit. The dangers of working with lead were not understood at the time.
9. Celluloid Dolls Were Built From The Same Chemical As Gunpowder
Celluloid dolls were popular from the late 1880s through the 1940s. They’re thin, hollow, and usually have glass eyes and a pale complexion. Unfortunately, celluloid is made from nitrocellulose, the same stuff in smokeless gunpowder, so the dolls were highly flammable and could burn up in seconds if left too close to a gas lamp, fireplace, or stove. After World War II, manufacturers switched to the more stable vinyl.
10. Little Lady Electric Stoves Plugged Straight Into The Wall
“Little Lady” toy electric stoves were miniature kitchen ranges made by American companies, including Empire Ltd., for little girls to play with during the 1920s and 1930s. They were made of heavy gauge sheet metal and plugged directly into wall outlets. Exposed coils that could reach temperatures in excess of 500 degrees Fahrenheit enabled children to bake small cakes or even to boil water, but could also lead to shocks and burns, and in some cases house fires. Unlike later toy ovens, these models had no insulation and did not automatically shut off.
11. Nuremberg Toy Kitchens Cooked With Real Fire And Scalding Oil
Crafted by German artisans in Nuremberg, working toy kitchens served a practical purpose. In order to learn how to manage a household, girls used these miniature homes to practice cooking. Unlike decorative dollhouses, Nuremberg Toy Kitchens (Nürnberger Puppenkuchen) were made with metal and wood, and included iron stoves that burned coal, wood, or alcohol, as well as brass kettles and copper pans. Girls struck matches and heated oil in which they fried tiny eggs. Burns from hot cooking oil or open flames happened, but parents considered them the price to pay for useful training.
12. Gebrüder Heubach's Character Dolls Wore Permanent Weeping Faces
Character dolls were meant to look as realistic as possible, with faces that expressed actual emotions seen in children, instead of idealized beauty. Deep frowns, crying faces with actual tears molded on, mouths open to scream, or sullen pouts typify the character dolls that the Gebrüder Heubach porcelain firm in Thuringia, Germany, began producing around 1900. These bisque dolls were sold as fine playthings for children.
13. Poor Pitiful Pearl Was Designed By William Steig To Break Your Heart
Poor Pitiful Pearl, a creation of The New Yorker cartoonist William Steig, later credited with writing the picture book that inspired Shrek, was released in 1958. Her sad face, with downturned eyes and a pout, along with her patched dress, scuffed shoes, and tattered headscarf, was a far cry from the glamorous fashion dolls of the time. The doll’s manufacturer, Brookglad Creations, also included an alternate party dress so the child could rescue Pearl herself from her impoverished circumstances.
14. The Dentist Bank Turned Tooth Extraction Into A Coin-Saving Game
Designed around 1880 by Charles A. Bailey for the J. & E. Stevens Company of Connecticut, the Dentist Bank shows a patient sitting in a dentist’s chair while an oversized dentist bearing an equally oversized pair of pliers approaches to perform his grisly task. A coin pushed into the dentist’s pocket activated a lever which made the dentist lurch backward and knock the patient off balance, sending them both toppling over and the coin clattering into a receptacle. The slapstick antics of this heavy cast-iron toy brought a sense of humor and play to the drudgery of saving money.
15. Kobe's Popping-Eye Automata Sent Carved Eyes Flying On Wooden Stalks
During Japan’s Meiji period, artisans carved toys made of dark hardwood in the port city of Kobe, known as Kobe-ningyo. These dolls, which depicted demons known as oni, musicians, or drunken men, were known for their comedic value instead of being horrifying. A peg-and-wire mechanism inside was activated by a crank on the doll’s side, popping out glass eyes on wooden stalks and a long red tongue. These comical caricatures were sold in Kobe as playthings and souvenirs.
16. George Clarke's Creeping Baby Doll Crawled On Exposed Iron Gears
George Pemberton Clarke, an American inventor, patented the mechanical crawling baby doll in 1871. Far from adorable, it was very loud as its gears ground and clanked. It had an inexpressive painted face, and its painted plaster limbs were dressed in a baby’s gown. Its internal clockwork was exposed, and its body consisted of an iron-and-brass frame equipped with two large iron wheels underneath its belly that allowed it to “crawl” around on the floor once set in motion by an iron winding key.
17. Gilbert's Glass Blowing Set Softened Glass At 1,000 Degrees, Bare-Handed
From the 1920s through the 1930s, the A.C. Gilbert Company sold a home Glass Blowing Set, which came with an alcohol lamp, blowpipes, and glass tubing. According to the instructions, children were to hold the tubing over the open flame of the alcohol lamp and wait for the glass to soften, at around 1,000 degrees Fahrenheit, then remove the tubing from the flame with their bare hands and begin blowing into the tubing to create small glass animals, test tubes, pipettes, etc. Not only did the set come without safety goggles or heat-resistant gloves, but it recommended that children use their bare hands.
18. Victorian Funeral Playsets Taught Children To Stage Their Own Burials
Miniature funeral sets, complete with a glass-paned hearse, velvet-lined coffin, and tiny mourners clad in black, were a common morbid toy of the era. Children used these to hold elaborate burials and funerals, complete with a procession and eulogy for dead pets and broken dolls. Parents weren’t creeped out by the morbid toy, either. They encouraged their children to engage in funeral play as a way to learn mourning practices and cope with grief, since the death of children was commonplace. Toy makers in Europe and America produced these through the 1800s.
19. Teething Rattles Were Carved From Wolf Teeth And Protective Coral
Handles of red coral branches, polished animal bone, or actual wolf and boar teeth set in sterling silver sockets, and strung with tiny bells, were fashioned by silversmiths in the 1700s and 1800s as rattles for babies of wealthy families to chew on and soothe sore gums. Red coral was also thought to ward off sickness and evil spirits.
20. Victorian Wax Dolls Had Human Hair, And Faces That Could Melt
Some of the most lifelike antique dolls were made from wax. Between the 1840s and 1890s, exclusive English doll families Pierotti and Montanari poured liquid beeswax into molds to make heads and limbs that had a skin-like appearance and texture. To give the dolls hair, tiny holes were poked in the still-soft heads with a heated needle and real human hair was inserted one strand at a time. Combined with glass eyes, the dolls could resemble sleeping babies. Wax, however, can slump or even melt when exposed to heat, and these dolls could become deformed if left near a fireplace or in direct sunlight.
This content was created with the help of AI.