A will is supposed to spell out who gets someone’s money after they die, but it can also leave a terrible mess behind. Wealthy Toronto lawyer Charles Vance Millar promised his remaining fortune to whichever local mother had the most children during a set period after his death. What first looked like an eccentric joke became the Great Stork Derby, a desperate chance for struggling families to escape poverty during the Depression. But when it was time to hand over the money, who would the courts decide actually qualified?
1. Charles Vance Millar, The Toronto Lawyer Who Loved Testing Human Greed
Charles Vance Millar left behind one of Toronto’s more colorful wills. A wealthy bachelor, Millar had amassed his considerable fortune as a lawyer and through his many investments, including a brewery holding company and a stagecoach company. But he also reportedly had a penchant for dropping dollar bills on Yonge Street and lurking to observe the guilty looks people gave one another before snatching them off the ground.
Millar died with no wife or children, and his will became his final, greatest experiment in human nature, asking whether people would prove worthy of his money.
2. Millar Died Mid-Argument Over A Point Of Law
Millar met his death in dramatic circumstances. While Millar was having lunch at a Toronto hotel with two fellow lawyers on Halloween in 1926, a difference of opinion arose over a point of law.
The three decided to settle the matter by reference to a law book in Millar’s office, and, as the elevator was out of order, 72-year-old Millar raced ahead up three flights of stairs. He had barely reached his chair and opened the book before a heart attack claimed his life.
3. Millar's Will Was A String Of Traps For The Greedy
When Millar’s will was unsealed in November 1926, it seemed almost like a dare. A minister who had been acquitted of killing a hotelkeeper was pointedly excluded from it, and others were less fortunate still.
Shares in the brewery were bequeathed to teetotal lodges and ministers if they would run the business. Shares in a racetrack went to two outspoken anti-gambling crusaders as well as to a racetrack owner. The crusaders passed their shares on to charity, but the owner kept his. Millar was testing principles against payouts, again and again.
4. A Jamaican House Left To Three Lawyers Who Hated Each Other
Millar also played cruel practical jokes, knowing full well that three leading Toronto lawyers, T.P. Galt, J.D. Montgomery, and James Haverson, hated each other.
His will stated that these three were to become joint owners of his vacation home in Jamaica, with the provision that they must live together in the house. The joke, however, existed only on paper, since, before Millar’s death, he had sold the house.
5. Clause 10 Promised A Fortune To Toronto's Busiest Mother
Clause 10 of Millar’s will, which he admitted was “uncommon and capricious” and which acknowledged his “folly in gathering and retaining more than I required,” specified that his executors should hold his remaining money (about $300,000) in trust for ten years and then give the entire sum to the Toronto mother who had registered the most children born during that decade.
6. Toronto Newspapers Dismissed The Will As A Freak Document
Clause 10 was more than a laugh to be shared over morning coffee. When it became public in November of 1926, the will was widely described by Toronto newspapers as a “freak document,” and many legal pundits concurred.
For the time being, the counting-by-births clause was simply a quirky provision, but most legal observers assumed it would be thrown out of court before a penny was paid.
7. The 1929 Crash Turned Millar's Joke Into A Lifeline
Clause 10 stopped seeming like a rich man’s joke to thousands of working-class families who, after the stock market crash of 1929, found themselves unemployed and on Toronto’s municipal relief rolls.
As the effects of the Depression worsened through the early 1930s, even desperate mothers looking for ways to feed their children saw some promise in Millar’s seemingly bottomless wealth. Competition to register qualifying births was fierce.
8. Millar's Fortune Topped $500,000 While Toronto Starved
The fact that Torontonians were suffering through the Depression only increased focus on the contest. That was especially true since Millar’s estate continued to grow throughout the 1930s thanks to dividends from his investments in a tunnel company and brewery stock.
When the money was finally paid out, the trust exceeded $500,000 (around $9 million today).
9. Ontario Tried To Seize The Fortune With Bill 141
Then, in March of 1932, it looked like the whole affair might come to an abrupt end. Ontario’s Conservative premier, George Henry, introduced legislation, Bill 141, to void Clause 10 as being against public policy.
The bill would have passed Millar’s remaining fortune to the government, to be used to endow scholarships at the University of Toronto. If this measure had passed, all the derby’s moms would have been shut out of the race entirely.
10. Ontarians Revolted Against Bill 141 And Killed It
Ontario Premier Henry’s plan to take Millar’s fortune sparked outrage across Ontario. Commentators and Ontarians alike bemoaned what they saw as an egregious example of government overreach, arguing that taking someone’s fortune could send the wrong message about everyone’s right to decide for themselves what happens to their things after they’re gone.
The backlash was strong enough that Henry’s government rescinded Bill 141 later in 1932.
11. Lillian Kenny Gave Birth 11 Times, More Than Any Other Mother In The Race
Lillian Kenny had given birth 11 times in the contest’s ten years, more than any other competing mother.
Two of the 11 babies were stillborn, a fact that at the time seemed an insignificant detail but would later prove crucial. Kenny and her family lived in slum conditions characteristic of working-class Toronto during the Depression, and she received municipal relief. The Toronto mother was now the frontrunner.
12. A Rat Bite Killed Lillian Kenny's Infant Son In 1933
Lillian Kenny’s 3-month-old son, Patrick, died in 1933 from an infection after being bitten by rats in the family’s substandard home. Kenny stayed in the race despite her grief as the fight for Millar’s fortune went on.
Patrick’s death was just one example of the dire straits many relief-dependent families faced during the Depression, often forced to live in overcrowded, unsanitary housing.
13. Pauline Mae Clarke's Ten Children Tested The Will's Wording
By 1936, during the contest decade, 24-year-old Pauline Mae Clarke had given birth to 10 children. When the contest began, she was known to the press only as “Mrs. X,” a pseudonym used out of concern for her own privacy.
After separating from her husband, Clarke bore five more children with an unmarried partner, Harold Madill. Her case prompted a national debate over whether a child born to unmarried parents should be considered a “child” in the context of the will.
14. Grace Bagnato Helped Immigrants, Then Lost On A Technicality
Grace Bagnato was another prolific mother. Nine of her 13 children were born during the contest decade. She worked as a court interpreter, helping Toronto’s Italian immigrants in the neighborhood known as the Ward navigate the legal system when they did not speak English.
But Bagnato was ruled ineligible because her husband was not a naturalized Canadian during some of the births. It took decades, but a plaque was finally erected in Bagnato’s honor in 2003.
15. Premier Hepburn Called The Derby Revolting And Disgusting
By 1936, Mitchell Hepburn, Ontario’s Liberal premier since 1934, called the derby “the most revolting, disgusting exhibition ever put on in a civilized country.”
While Hepburn may have disliked the event, he acknowledged the will was legally valid, and his government sought to ensure both sides in the legal fight over the estate would be treated fairly, and neither would be financially crippled by legal costs. But unlike his predecessor, Hepburn’s government was unwilling to step in and put a stop to the derby.
16. Midnight On Halloween 1936 Closed The Birth Count Forever
At midnight on October 31, 1936, exactly 10 years after Millar’s death, the deadline under Clause 10 for counting births expired. The last-minute rush to register births overwhelmed Toronto’s vital statistics office. Every mother who made the deadline could only hope her tally would hold up once the lawyers got involved.
17. Thirty-Two Lawyers Crowded Osgoode Hall To Argue Over The Births
Thirty-two lawyers crowded into the courtroom of Toronto’s stately old Osgoode Hall to argue the case before senior judge William Edward Middleton. One relative, F.C. Taplay, claimed his wife was Millar’s cousin and argued Clause 10 should be thrown out, full stop. Every relative’s claim, including his, was rejected. The battle wasn’t over who was a Millar. It was over who counted as born to a Millar.
18. Courts Excluded Stillbirths And Children Born Out Of Wedlock
Millar’s will never defined the word “child.” When the will was contested, Judge Middleton applied the then-current English common-law rules to the term.
Under those rules, a child must be born alive and legitimate. Thus, two of Lillian Kenny’s 11 births and five of Pauline Mae Clarke’s ten children, born to her and her unmarried partner, would not have been considered children under Millar’s will. These restrictions were not in the will itself. They were added after the fact by the judge and the appeal courts.
19. Canada's Top Court Upheld The Will, However Foolish
Disqualified mothers appealed, arguing Clause 10 encouraged reckless childbearing and violated public policy. In December 1937, the Supreme Court of Canada rejected their appeal. Writing for the bench, Chief Justice Lyman Duff reasoned that no matter how foolish or eccentric a person’s will may be, it should be given effect so long as it does not violate an actual law.
The case defended Millar’s right to do as he wished with his own money, not the wisdom of his peculiar contest.
20. Four Mothers Split Half A Million Dollars In 1938
In 1938, Judge Middleton ordered the estate’s final distribution. Annie Katherine Smith, Kathleen Ellen Nagle, Lucy Alice Timleck, and Isabel Mary Maclean each had nine verified, legitimate births, and they split the estate’s more than $500,000 four ways. Three of the women, though, had to repay the city for the welfare relief their families had received during the Depression.
To avoid further court fights, the executors also settled out of court with two more claimants, Lillian Kenny and Pauline Mae Clarke, who each received $12,500. At the end of the decade of hardship, four women walked away rich and two much less so.
This content was created with the help of AI.